PDA

View Full Version : MERANTAU (2009) Review


mpm74
01-22-2011, 08:44 PM
Young Yuda (Iko Uwais) has reached the point in his life where he must leave his hometown, prove his manhood, and find success on his own. It’s his way of following a family tradition known as “Merantau.” So Yuda, a Silat (a Southeast Asian fighting method) expert, heads to the big city of Jakarta, with hopes to make a living by teaching children his martial arts style.

Upon his arrival, he saves a woman (Sisca Jessica) from gangsters, who happen to be connected to a sinister sex trade operation. What follows is a violent adventure that leaves Yuda with a lot more “Merantau” than he bargained for.

Essentially, “Merantau” is an Indonesian film, but it’s important to note that it’s directed by Gareth Evans, a Welsh born writer/director (known of his ultra-violent, critically acclaimed debut feature “Footsteps”). It was during the filming of a documentary series “The Mystic Arts of Indonesia: Pencak Silat,” that he took special notice in Iko Uwais, a charismatic young man with a solid Silat background. Evans immediately handpicked him for the role of “Yuda,” the main character in a martial arts movie script he had been working on. The rest is history...

What’s makes “Merantau” so special is Gareth Evans - he’s one hell of a filmmaker. This is a director who treats a martial arts movie with a little more passion than the next guy. Cinematography (beautiful), plot (simple, yet effective), soundtrack (non-tacky) and performances (Iko Uwais has a bright future) aside, we have ourselves a perfectly paced film with a build up that pays off with every minutes that passes.

The action choreography in “Merantau” is impressive, but far from the best. It's not as fast and furious as Jackie Chan’s in his heyday (80’s Jackie Chan movies are practically the blueprint for what they wanted to achieve in the action department); Nor is it as intense and brutal as any of Tony Jaa’s movies. However, when the fights are judged within the film’s entire context, they’re actually more exciting. It’s amazing what good content can do to action sequences.

There’s not a lot of that slow motion bullshit or physical circus acts (hopping through hoops or swinging off animals) shoved down are faces. Instead of fight after fight, our hero takes time to catch his breath; Sometimes even meditating to prepare for the next wave of destruction. Gone are the non-action, mediocre filler scenes. No stupid sidekick for comedy relief. Everything is filmed with quality in mind.

Iko Uwais is not a poor man’s Tony Jaa (at first glance of the poster or even the trailer, I can see why some would think that). He’s a natural who is able to pull off a tough guy role without being overly robotic. Pay attention to the way he hangs up the phone, steps out of the booth, and walks towards the gang to save the woman. He comes across like a real badass.

The bottom line is “Merantau” is a great movie, with an awesome team of choreographers working on the action; And a skillful director who put 100% concentration on everything else. It’s no wonder why “Merantau” works on so many levels.

OpiumKungFuCracker
01-22-2011, 10:41 PM
I really enjoy the feeling of being surprise by a certain movie that's not usually in the Martial Arts crop... Silat which I never seen in a movie before, was awesome, and different... Be cool if G Evans tackles more different types of Martial arts from different countries on display...

mpm74
01-22-2011, 11:09 PM
Yeah, he's pretty bad director. I was surprised. Much MUCH better than Tony Jaa and his buddies. Those guys have no sense of pacing. lol

Cool guy, too. He knows his stuff. He's a big fan of Jackie Chan's 80's stuff, you can tell.

BaronK
01-23-2011, 02:30 AM
Thought the movie played fine but the action didn't do it for me. It felt like Jackie Chan lite. While the style was silat, it came off too kickboxy. The fight scene that everyone agrees was best, was the elevator fight. That was also the fight with the best silat display.
The movie is full of silat on display but it gets lost in the actual style of the choreography. The choreography and rhythm and reactions are so based on the kickboxing style that it doesn't feel like it's supposed to be a silat featured movie.
Hopefully the future productions will have more silat vs silat, or silat vs other styles to bring it out more. If you're going to have a movie feature a style, you have to feed the choreography the style's techniques mixed in. The kickboxing/stunt style/rhythm and reactions aren't the way to do it.

mpm74
01-23-2011, 03:41 AM
It felt like Jackie Chan lite.

I can totally see that. I thought there was enough of it's own personality to come across on it's own as well.

I'll have to look up some silat videos or something, because I'm totally unfamiliar with that style (other than what i've seen in the movie, which - judging from what you're saying - isn't a good representation).

BaronK
01-23-2011, 05:24 AM
Silat can be very rough. It also lends itself extremely well to kung fu type choreography. Much of the elevator fight played that way. I'll put some vids up in the General section.

OpiumKungFuCracker
01-23-2011, 12:31 PM
Elevator fight scene was bad ass, maybe it was shot really close and tightly which made it seemed more authentic, but I really don't know much about Silat...