PDA

View Full Version : Chinatown Kid (1977) Review


mpm74
04-24-2011, 07:46 PM
http://www.cityonfire.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/ChinatownKid_GoldenSwallow_SC36-207x300.jpg

I know this movie has been covered to death (reviews, discussions, etc), but hey, here it is anyways...

By Mighty Peking Man

After getting into trouble with both the Hong Kong police and the local crime syndicate (headed by Johnny Wang Lung-Wei), Tang Dong (Alexander Fu Sheng) heads to San Francisco to hide out and lead a normal work life. Upon his arrival, he gets a job at a Chinatown restaurant where befriends a co-worker named Yang Jian Wen (Sun Chien), a student from Taiwan.

Unfortunately, It doesn’t take long for Tang Dong to find himself in yet another predicament. While on a routine stop at a laundromat, Tang Dong notices men extorting money from the owners. With extreme ease, Tang Dong fights them off and scares them away. As it turns out, the men Tang Dong took on were members of the Green Dragon gang (headed by Lo Meng).

When word gets around that Tang Dong single-handedly beat up a pack of Green Dragon members, a rival gang called the White Dragon gangsters (headed by Phillip Kwok) decide to recruit Tang Dong.

What follows is saga of struggle, wealth, betrayal, friendship and morality…

“Chinatown Kid” is one hell of a movie. It’s paced just right with a little bit of everything: comedy, gangsterism, kung fu and even some violent shoot out sequences.

The charismatic Alexander Fu Sheng shines throughout. His boyish charm works perfectly for his character’s tough, but naive personality. As for Sun Chien? I like the guy, but he plays an odd character who feels a little out of place. I keep all my reviews spoil-free, so you’ll have to watch this movie to see what I mean.

Along with “The Brave Archer,” “Shaolin Temple,” and “The Naval Commandos”; “Chinatown Kid” features cast members who would be widely known as the “Venoms” a year later. It’s only Sun Chien, Lo Meng and Philip Kwok who have chunky roles; Lu Feng and Chiang Sheng are barely in the picture; Wai Pai is the only member who is absent. On an interesting note, this is the only film where you get to see the Venom members sport bell-bottoms and shoot firearms.

“Chinatown kid” also features a lineup of groovy babes: Shirley Yu Sha Li (Life Gamble), Jenny Tseng Yan Lei (Boxer Rebellion), Shaw Yum Yum (Human Lanterns) and last, but not least, a cameo from Kara Hui (My Young Auntie).

“Chinatown Kid” has been compared to Brian DePalma’s “Scarface” (1983). In fact, it’s easy to imagine Giorgio Moroder’s theme playing in the background as Tang Dong rises to power. I personally doubt Brian DePalma drew inspiration from “Chinatown Kid,” but the two movies do share a lot of the same qualities, both visually and in plot. But then again, this is Brian DePalma we’re talking about (he’s often criticized for ripping off everyone from Alfred Hitchcock to Sergei M. Eisenstein).

WARNING: The Celestial DVD has a completely different “happy” ending with a chunk of violence cut out, as well as other changes here and there. What sucks is the Celestial version is the only legit version available (although it’s currently out of print). The only other options you have is to find an old Southgate VHS tape or purchase the shady Pan Media DVD. I’m not the biggest bootleg fan, but It’s situations like these where I’m totally for them. For more details about the difference between the two versions/endings, click here (http://www.teako170.com/chinatown.html). Watch out for spoilers.

The Celestial DVD is a good way of viewing the alternative ending as an extra if you’re curious, otherwise it’s an unnecessary version that only hurts the film.

Blood Sword
04-24-2011, 08:12 PM
"celestial" cut is not as bad as it`s reputation though scissored fight scenes in the end hurted lot.
It`s worth picking if u see it at local second hand store.
I have celestial dvd and vcd...But eventually if/as this gets usa release I get it!
Nice review:bigsmile:

mpm74
04-24-2011, 08:30 PM
Yeah, I actually used to to own it. It does makes a great historic piece for an alternate ending (especially compared to now, where they film alternate endings for the sake of having an extra on a special edition release).

I've seen the Southgate VHS version from back of the day MANY times. I guess I'm just used to it. Besides, a Chang Cheh films is always better when all bloody hell breaks loose. =D

mpm74
04-24-2011, 08:35 PM
Does anyone have the article written by Linn Haynes about the Celestial process?

I clicked on the link that teako's article provides, but I think it's broken (http://pub127.ezboard.com/fhongkongdvdsgeneral.showMessage?topicID=6464.topi c&index=29). :(


If someone can give me a rundown or remembers what was written in that link, that would be great.

OpiumKungFuCracker
04-24-2011, 11:45 PM
Is Tarantino the new Brian DePalma??

teako170
04-24-2011, 11:51 PM
I clicked on the link that teako's article provides, but I think it's broken (http://pub127.ezboard.com/fhongkongdvdsgeneral.showMessage?topicID=6464.topi c&index=29). :(
.

I will update that. Thanks for reminder.
In the meantime....

http://www.teako170.com/linncomments.jpg

mpm74
04-25-2011, 12:04 AM
Thanks Teako... looking forward to reading that. And thanks for your great Chinatown Kid article comparison. I didn't realize how different they really were (other than the obvious).

Is Tarantino the new Brian DePalma??

I'd say! Have you ever seen that really early DeNiro movie that was directed by DePalma? (it's called like "Hi, Mom" or something). CLASSIC! lol

I love both directors, but QT has a better track record. Doesn't hurt that he makes 1 film every 5 or 6 years! lol

MarsHarmony
04-25-2011, 06:45 AM
I keep all my reviews spoil-free, so you’ll have to watch this movie to see what I mean. (mpm74)

I so agree with your 'spoil-free' philosophy, and thanks for writing a great review of Chinatown Kid, well done indeed.

@teako170 - Thanks for sharing the page of Linn Haynes post about the Celestial process, it is always a pleasure to read his words.

mpm74
04-25-2011, 03:55 PM
Thanks for reading, MarsHarmony.

Fu Sheng "will be a hard many to follow"

Blood Sword
04-25-2011, 04:36 PM
well,"boyish charm" works sure better here than in na cha the great...

nectarsis
04-25-2011, 05:25 PM
Cool read *bumps Chinatown Kid much higher on my watch list*

mpm74
04-26-2011, 02:27 AM
Cool read *bumps Chinatown Kid much higher on my watch list*

Ah, man. Get on it. =D It's great. Thanks for reading. Let us know what you think.

OpiumKungFuCracker
04-28-2011, 11:02 AM
When you're poor you gotta struggle....

OpiumKungFuCracker
04-29-2011, 01:27 AM
The bootleg version I had makes the Panmedia version look like the Criterion Collection... The saturation and colors were all over the damn place, I thought Fu Sheng was hispanic for a second there, or maybe he is???

mpm74
04-29-2011, 03:00 AM
I have 2nd Panmedia disc (has the Southgate version and a dubbed IVL transfer).

Hats off to Panmedia. They'r a bunch of greasy slimeballs, but where else are you going to find the Southgate version? I don't even own a VCR, and I'm not going to buy a used tape for $30+...

OpiumKungFuCracker
09-06-2011, 05:53 PM
Scarface bluray just release today and so I thought of this movie which still has not gotten a single decent release on dvd or bluray.. I mean WTF is the hold up??? This movie is the quintessential Gangster movie...

bratty
09-07-2011, 12:08 PM
anyone know if there is any difference between the Southgate edition and Forum Home Video? I've got the Forum version. They have good quality tapes so it's not like a late 80s Saturn tape or something. Anyone know which tape came out first , and if there is any difference? I would dig it up and check out the ending but it's (very well) packed. (I'm getting ready to move to Chinatown myself!)