|
|
#1 | |
|
Administrator
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 1,050
|
Classic Shaw Brothers soundtracks coming to CD
http://www.kungfucinema.com/?p=3199 Quote:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#2 |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 566
|
That's really cool. :)
Thanks for the tidbit. |
|
|
|
|
|
#3 |
|
Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 356
|
Haven't most of these songs been in circulation already (both in mp3's uploaded on this website and through p2p programs)? I guess having anything Shaw Brothers related being released is a plus, but I would have been more excited if there were a wider variety of music available, or shaw brothers music included that was not just from De Wolfe (which is btw harder to find and identify). Just my two cents.
|
|
|
|
|
|
#4 |
|
Member
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 246
|
I'd be curious to listen to these to see which ones sound familiar to me. I tend to categorize the music in these films as either a) coming from familiar Hollywood/Italian western soundtracks (e.g. the Bond films, Morricone) or b) coming from a completely different music library. I used to make the mistake of thinking that if the music sounded "Chinese" in orchestration then it was probably an original score by the composer actually listed. Then, at some point I either learned or figured out that it was simply coming from a more "Chinese"-sounding music library.
So the questions I have are: Did the De Wolfe Music Library provide the "Chinese"-sounding music as well as the other cues that didn't come from familiar movie soundtracks? Or did the Chinese cues come from another library? Why was there so little attempt to come up with appropriate scores for these films? I'm not speaking about the Huangmei operas, of course. Those films required a whole different set of musical tasks and I'm assuming those orchestrations were unique to those films, even if the music wasn't. But, for me, it all comes down to this: why, after making an epic adaptation of a classic Chinese novel, "The Water Margin," in 1972, didn't the filmmakers come up with a real score for a film they'd put such hard work into? Instead, they lathered on cues from Dominic Frontiere's score for HANG 'EM HIGH. When the film played in the U.S. as SEVEN BLOWS OF THE DRAGON (shortened by 40 minutes), it had a different, somewhat better score. Provided, I'm sure, by another music library. |
|
|
|
|
|
#5 | |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 1,834
|
Much of The Water Margin's score is from Uriah Heep's Salisbury
Quote:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#6 |
|
Administrator
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 1,050
|
SamuraiDana, you pose some good questions that deserve better answers than I can provide but I'll take a stab at them.
I'll start with the second question.The way in which Shaw Brothers and lesser studios cranked out films for quick profit suggest that there wasn't time or funds available to invest in original film scores. The fact that Sync Sound, recording live sound on set, wasn't even used regularly in Hong Kong until the 1990s also suggests that sound in general was an afterthought for the producers. Another issue seems to be intended markets. Early on, SB was targeting mostly Chinese audiences and I believe this is why most of their early wuxia films, for instance, do tend to use Chinese-styled music undoubtedly not provided by De Wolfe. But after KING BOXER was introduced to America and was followed by Bruce Lee's films, it's likely that SB saw the value in borrowing Western music to better sell the films overseas. It was probably far less expensive to license music from a library than to find local artists, build a recording studio and pay composers to craft original works for each production. On top of that, it would have undoubtedly slowed post-production, resulting in fewer films being released each year. Given that films rarely ran for more than two weeks in theaters, this would have definitely hurt their annual box office takes. The bottom line is that SB favored quantity over quality. While this resulted in more films for us to watch it's still a shame as we could have ended up with more films being treated with the same measure of critical reverence as King Hu's works or those of Akira Kurosawa. What's doubly a shame is that I have heard some fantastic Chinese-themed orchestral work performed by the likes of the Taipei Symphony Orchestra that would make wonderful, rousing soundtracks to period kung fu and wuxia movies of the 1970s. Original scores to period martial arts movies today tend to be too melancholy, bland or pretentious, not unlike some of the films themselves. |
|
|
|
|
|
#7 |
|
Member
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 196
|
De Wolfe does have traditional chinese (and japanese) music lps by chinese composers and lps that could pass for chinese too. IMO, the traditional music Shaw used was too bland and basic. It was in their best interest to use a variety of library music. It's a given that the actors movies elements and concepts are chinese but the music doesn't have to be to convey the moods and atmospheres.
__________________
http://hatembargo.blogspot.com "You use dirty tricks I'll get you! A sly and cunning knave like you will never know my name!" -Another dead hero |
|
|
|
|
|
#8 | |
|
Member
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 246
|
Quote:
Anyway, just for the record, Shaw Bros. was using cues from James Bond films and Morricone soundtracks (e.g. FOR A FEW DOLLARS MORE) long before KING BOXER and the Bruce Lee films. Just checking my notes on SB films seen in the past two years I found four from 1967-72 that had such cues: THE ASSASSIN (1967), RAPE OF THE SWORD (1967), THE SWIFT KNIGHT (1971), and THE DELIGHTFUL FOREST (1972) and I'm sure there were quite a few more. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
#9 |
|
Member
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 196
|
Okay so I bought this and if I was a casual fan I would be more than satisfied... but you know I'm not a casual fan. My main issue is that some of the movies are wrong. I thought maybe it was an error on the sites' behalf like one site got the official tracklist typed in it wrong and everyone else copied but nope... they're in the book like that. Some of these movies I've never seen so those I can't confirm and others I have to watch again. Here are the right movies for the ones I noticed...
02. Horror House - Rebel Intruders/Shaolin Prince [Not Marco Polo aka Four Assassins] 24. Industrial Complex - ??? [I've heard this but not in "The Master" not even in "The Master of Kungfu"] 34. Sentry - Life Gamble/Brave Archer [Not Masked Avengers] Did they do a good job otherwise? Sure they did. IMO, the standout tracks are 2.Horror House, 3.Suppression, 9.Rite de la Terre, 10.Violence, 29.Bitter Lemons, 33.Face to Face, 36.Jackboot, and 41.Manoeuvers. While the book is informative, it didn't have the type of info I was looking for. I was moreso interested in the source material but they didn't say. However, there is a cool "treatment" image of a play by play sound scheme. Atleast I now know a few more track names from Invincible Shaolin that I didn't know before. They have a couple of other interesting official Shaw documents too. Shaw literally paid for the entire libraries of DW and their 3 subsidiaries... 2 copies of each record I believe. WOW! I'll be IDing Shaw forever. When they advertise it as music from "Dirty Ho," "Return to the 36th Chamber," and "Invincible Shaolin," they really do mean that. For them to have had so much access, I would have expected more variety or better choices but I'm pretty sure they had their own criteria and favorites among themselves. A clever thing to do would have been to list alternate movies that used the same cues. I wouldn't have been fooled but somebody would have. If they made another one would I buy it? Probably. Unbiased I'd rate it 4/5. Biased, I'd rate it a 2.5/5. I would send them an email asking what was sourced from where but I don't think they would tell me lol.
__________________
http://hatembargo.blogspot.com "You use dirty tricks I'll get you! A sly and cunning knave like you will never know my name!" -Another dead hero |
|
|
|
|
|
#10 |
|
Member
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 196
|
I got mine on ebay... good ol ebay. Would you believe I got a used copy of a NEW CD that's really not even out yet!!!!!!?????? It's always somethin...they did list it as brand new so I'm going to file a dispute as soon as I get time to photograph my evidence. There's more on there but from different people. I doubt lightning would strike twice.
On the positive side, I managed to find and order another rare LP thanks to the sound scheme sheet. I would pay for those sheets if someone would sell them (in bulk). There would be no more IDing. I would simply have to find the record/cd.
__________________
http://hatembargo.blogspot.com "You use dirty tricks I'll get you! A sly and cunning knave like you will never know my name!" -Another dead hero |
|
|
|
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |