REVIEW: ‘Ninja Assassin’ (2009)

  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • PDF
  • Print
by Mark Pollard | November 27, 2009
Editor's Rating:
User Rating:
VN:F [1.5.4_809]
Rating: 3.6/5 (23 votes cast)

NINJA ASSASSIn (2009)

Korean pop star Rain ably transforms into the leanest, meanest killing machine since Sonny Chiba was ripping out balls with his bare hands in THE STREET FIGHTER films. From the opening bloodbath, director James McTeigue and producers Andy and Larry Wachowski have succeeded in substantially upgrading the American ninja movie into a fast-moving and gruesomely satisfying fight fest every bit as efficient in its pacing, visuals and highly sophisticated choreography as Rain is in bending an unwieldy chain-whip dagger to his will. They manage all of this despite apparent flaws I anticipated would be damning yet were incapable of dampening an entirely fun and engaging actioner that rarely lets pesky character or plot development get in between a hail of shuriken and their target.

NINJA ASSASSIn (2009)

I say all of this coming into this movie as a skeptic. I had a lot of questions going in. How could the “Justin Timberlake” of Korea become a credible martial arts lead with virtually no prior screen fighting skill? How could I stand to watch an entire film populated by the same rapid cutting style of editing seen in the trailers? Would the digital effects kill my suspension of disbelief? I can say that with few exceptions, my concerns were largely sliced apart into bite-sized morsels within the first 15 minutes.

The film opens with a massacre of triad thugs by ninja that’s so violent and explicit that it puts many so-called splatter films to shame. Readily apparent are the use of digital effects in the display of blood works and the liberal use of darkly lit, tight shots rapidly edited together. Being the old school action guy that I am who relishes long takes of skilled stunt performers exchanging meticulously choreographed fisticuffs, I would normally scoff at such new school tricks but something about how McTeigue pulls it all together works with the idea of super-skilled killers no one is meant to see unless they want to be seen. Or maybe it’s the unrestrained stylistic violence, rekindling the thrill of watching films like THE CROW. Perhaps it’s the fight choreography which immediately exceeded my expectations in the depth of its planning and skill of its execution.

This opening spurt of ultra violence is followed by the inconspicuous entry of Rain in a laundromat, presumably washing the blood off his black ninja garb from some past job. Here, Rain takes on his first opponent, a female ninja expertly disguised as a laudnromat patron. This establishes a vital aspect of ninja tactics, the ability to blend in, not just in shadow, but among otherwise unsuspecting people. Unfortunately, this is never really explored further but frankly, there wouldn’t have been time because from here the pace picks up as we’re introduced to Europol agents Maslow (Ben Miles) and Mika (Naomie Harris), whose investigation of various high-profile political assassinations sets them on the trail of the Ozunu ninja clan. Interspersed are flashbacks that reveal Raizo’s grueling training as an orphan taken in and mentored by the ruthless ninja master Ozunu (Sho Kosugi).

For fans of classic ninja flicks like REVENGE OF THE NINJA (1983) and PRAY FOR DEATH (1985), the presence of veteran action star Sho Kosugi as the villainous Ozunu will be welcome. Using a voice sounding very similar to Mako in SAMURAI JACK, Kosugi is a potent foil for Raizo. He’s the supremely powerful, yet aged master who has given Raizo his skills yet tried to take away his humanity. This is nicely revealed in flashbacks that show how Raizo loses his closest friend as a result of Ozunu’s strict rules and this gradually widens a rift that finally erupts into a flurry of ninja-on-ninja action on a rooftop.

NINJA ASSASSIn (2009)

One of the strengths of NINJA ASSASSIN is that it provides heavy doses of thrilling combat between ninja, especially after Raizo comes to Mika’s rescue. From this point on the film becomes a frantic race from one massive battle to the next with an army of ninja creeping through the shadows as the heroes struggle to survive. The final matches between Raizo and his two main opponents are good but there is one all-out battle in an old abandoned power station that is mind-blowing in its presentation.

In addition to Kosugi, Rain’s other main opponent is played by DIE ANOTHER DAY villain Rick Yune. One disappointment is that his role was so small. He’s supposed to be Raizo’s main rival but we don’t get to know much about him or his abilities. So when these two square off, it doesn’t have the impact or provide the satisfaction that it should. In contrast, the film does much better in handling Rain’s friendly relationships with a female ninja and with Naomie Harris’ Europol character. Rain and Harris have adequate chemistry and even though there is no substantial development in their relationship, the script manages to steer clear of any racial stereotypes which is something I cannot thank the screenwriters enough for. After three RUSH HOUR movies, I’ve had my fill of that.

Action choreography was overseen by 87Eleven members Chad Stahelski, Jon Valera and Jonathan Eusebio, with additional fight choreography by Zhang Peng who previously worked with Brad Allen on HELLBOY 2. Prior to shooting, Rain spent six months training for his role and before that briefly worked with the 87Eleven team on the Wachowskis’ SPEED RACER. According to Stahelski, Rain was a very quick study when it came to his training on SPEED RACER, which ultimately led him to star in NINJA ASSASSIN. He performed most of his own stunts and kept pace with other stunt players for the most part.

Rain performs admirably throughout the film, both in his fight work and limited opportunities to act. It’s subtle but he definitely displays a measure of charm that goes beyond mere looks. As for his physical prowess, I couldn’t ask for a better performance from someone with little more than six months of screen fight training. This guy is a natural and needs to follow up with more action roles. I’m not big on pop stars turning to action as they rarely have the commitment or skill to earn the respect that a performer like Jet Li or Donnie Yen does through a lifetime of training. Rain is an exception.

NINJA ASSASSIn (2009)

I have mixed feeling about the depiction of ninja and their abilities in this film. On the one hand, they’re about as badass as ninja can get. These assassins mean business and I’m talking insta-kills left and right. Heads get chopped off, bodies are riddled with heavy shuriken that actually look capable of killing someone rather than causing mere superficial wounds. Limbs are severed and blood flows like crazy. These guys don’t play with their targets, blab on or engage in long, drawn out battles. The only exception on this last point is when ninja are evenly matched and this only occurs twice in the movie.

I like the slightly exaggerated and varied use of weapons. Giving Raizo a chain whip dagger as a main weapon was a brilliant idea to allow the character to perform more unconventional and interesting fighting moves not limited strictly to traditional ninjitsu. It’s obvious that the stunt team took liberties by incorporating wushu moves and Hong Kong-style fight work but it works. The chain whip also allows Raizo to effectively engage multiple targets at once from a variety of ranges.

Now what I have problems with in the depiction of ninja are their propensity to whisper ominously like “Others” from the TV series LOST and their ability to move like The Flash at times. You literally see them move at superhuman speeds, very similar to the ninja in the animated JACKIE CHAN ADVENTURES SERIES. It’s a very hokey effect that is added to the other superhuman ability to magically heal wounds. Then again, this isn’t any worse than past depictions of ninja burrowing through the ground at high speeds or disappearing into thin air. In the context of a Godfrey Ho or Chang Cheh ninja movie, NINJA ASSASSIN is a very effective update and perhaps viewers should look at the film from this perspective to best enjoy it.

One of the biggest early complaints about the movie is how dark it is, particularly during action sequences. It’s true. Most of the action intentionally takes place at night with limited lighting and it is often difficult to clearly see what is happening. It’s similar to how Batman fought in BATMAN BEGINS, yet there is far more going on during combat scenes in this film. If you consider how ninjas are supposed to operate in this movie it makes sense that we wouldn’t see everything they do. In some ways, I wish we saw less, particularly their ability to move at superhuman speeds.

NINJA ASSASSIn (2009)

What I would have liked to see though was more diversity in killing and stealth techniques. There is far too much dependence on shadows, shuriken and bladed weapons. When it comes to ninjas I want to see more dirty tricks. Where are the poisons, caltraps, flash bangs, hidden weapons, disguises, parachutes, wall-climbing gear, etc? I would expect the modern ninja to come packing a wide array of specialized equipment but I guess this clan is old school.

Another complaint is that the camera doesn’t pull away enough. For instance, during a sequences where ninjas chase Raizo through traffic I kept wanting to see at least one overhead shot of these warriors weaving through cars. The few wide shots we do get add so much to the film. In addition, the fight choreography was good enough that the editor should have dropped more cuts and alternate angles to let the audience see Rain and the stunt team do their magic. Unlike a lot of other Hollywood action films, many of the action cuts appear to be cosmetic rather than attempts mask poor skills.

Something else I have to comment on is the ninja-versus-Special Forces action. There are two main sequences, the first in the aforementioned power station and the other in a place I won’t mention so as not to spoil anything. For fans of epic genre-based screen carnage, these sequences are pure bliss. I nearly lost interest in the main plot during these sequences, they were so much fun to watch. The second sequence makes for one of the biggest payoffs I’ve seen in any action movie in recent memory. The only thing missing here was some wise-cracking, John McClane-type character shouting, “Say hello to the 21st Century mofos!”

After seeing this movie, I have to say, “When is the sequel coming?” I see great potential for the studio to build on this foundation. NINJA ASSASSIN was an origin story and a damn good one too. From here, a screenwriter could go almost anywhere by introducing rival clans, vampires, super villains, aliens, you name it. The world of NINJA ASSASSIN is just far enough outside of reality to justify the introduction of anything so long as it retains the same level of hardcore violence and fight work. Something a future installment could benefit from would be more humor, so long as it’s well written.

I honestly doubted this film could live up to the hype but it has. By ninja movie standards, NINJA ASSASSIN is a masterpiece. It honestly made me feel like a kid again, the same 12-year-old who used to froth at the mouth over films like NINJA III: THE DOMINATION and DUEL TO THE DEATH. Japan has produced more historically accurate depictions of ninja (and less historically accurate too) but they have rarely been this enjoyable to watch in action. James McTeigue displayed promise as an action director in V FOR VENDETTA and now he has proven he’s got the chops. If nothing else, this film should satisfy audiences who have been clamoring for serious, all-our ninja action and action films to embrace the same level of bloodletting seen in recent horror films. Aside from less-than-perfect digital squibs, I would put this movie into the same category as Sylvester Stallone’s RAMBO (2008). Both films deliver the goods when it comes to hardcore, epic destruction. Hold on… I just thought of the perfect match-up… Rambo vs. NINJA ASSASSIN-style ninjas. Seriously, Sly, Avi Lerner, the Wachowskis, somebody needs to get on it.

Related Topics

, , , ,

  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • PDF
  • Print

  • jinkazama
    A film always needs a good villain and kosugi is completely ominous in this. But there was one BIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIGGGGGGGG mistake, ninja used ninjatos, not bloody silver steel blades, ninjatos were black so as not to reflect light and they looked more badass, a trick these amateurs miss when they try to impersonate us !
  • Andre J
    This film, in my opinion, is the best martial arts film Hollywood has put out since Enter the Dragon. That's over 30 years man! I hope that there is a sequel so people can see more ninjas.
  • i like this movie. Remind me of Shogun Assassin.
  • Mike
    I saw Ninja Assasin the other day with a group of 16 people. Only 2 people liked the film, the rest including me thought it was awfull ! I really wanted to like this film but it failed on all parts. Bad story, bad fight scenes, bad acting, lots of logical errors..the list goes on.
    Ninja Assasin is THE dissapointment of the year. :(
  • chris_stoddard_78
    I agree with a lot of the things you said about NINJA ASSASSIN Mark and you're precise with the particular subject matters you write about with the comparisons to other movies and other refferences. I like that and it was well written.

    This movie was the first of it's kind in terms of how James McTeigue's ultra-violent theme (similar to HOSTEL and SAW) explodes and how he treats his ninja like monsters. The brutality and gore took off with heads rolling, torsos getting severed, faces being sliced like apples and geysers of blood spurts to add in the mix. Their introduction starts after the first few imnutes into the film where one slaughers his enemies one by one in a way the Xenomorphs killed their prey in ALIENS and how Neon killed in THE PROFESSIONAL.

    As a huge fan of action choreography, the swordplay and other fight designs in this film were crafted beautifully. It allowed Rain to use his main weapon, the knife-chain in the form of the Jouhyou "or rope-dart", where he twines and shoots it in different directions from long distances. The cinematography captured these sequences nicely and it relied on slick camera movements and slow-motion shots in the style of THE MATRIX.

    Compared to the martial arts/weaponry training Keanu received for six months for THE MATRIX, the stunt/fight choreographers only showed Rain a routine twice and he pulled off the moves extraordinary. Like you said Mark, that was commitment and skill because you don't find singers with no combat training turning into screen fighters with that level of commitment. I'll put him in the category with Donnie Yen and Jet Li.

    The fights were set in dark areas and they got a little claustrophobic because you couldn’t see everything that's going on but I think that was the idea. Of course, a ninja is supposed to be mysterious to judge the situation of the enemy. They use methods on their enemies to discover gaps, and enter enemy territories with carried out assassinations, arriving in secret so it would make sense for them to use the dark to arrive in secret.

    An overhead shot would've been a great addition to the traffic battle scene (as it was for Jackie Chan in WHO AM I in one sequence) to see more of what was going on and what Rain was doing but maybe they didn't have enough time to shoot some of the sequences that way or a possible "press-for-time" issue came about at the last minute.

    You seem like you have the proper tools to be a filmmaker Mark because you have creative ideas.

    Directed and written by Mark Pollard ladies and gentlemen. LOL

    I also agree with you on the RAMBO part because James McTeigue's ultra-violent take on ninjas dismembering their enemies, teleporting, using superhuman speed and throwing rapid hira-shurikens faster than bullets would be a perfect crossover and great challenge for RAMBO with the right script written by the right people; and a director who has a visual style to pull it off.

    A jungle set up for McTeigue's breed of ninja would be an interesting showdown for Sly's heroic former Green beret legend from the '80s.

    Maybe Sly himself could do it since he has shown that he can shoot good movies and has his own take on movies (THE EXPENDABLES and ROCKY BALBOA), resulting from 2008's RAMBO. That would be an entertaining piece of work if someone was to pull it off but from early reports, I'm trying to ignore the early drafts of the fifth movie. LOL

    I was very disappointed with the movie's first week numbers at the box office but of course, they would release NINJA ASSASSIN during the hype of NEW MOON and 2012. I believe if they would've released the film earlier or waited for that hype to wear down, then maybe the movie wouldn't have received verbal hira-shuriken attacks by critics (and the film being boring is absolutely false). Sometimes, I think that's a set up for box office failures of good movies, given the fact that the cast were relatively unknown and McTeigue is sort of new to the martial arts genre in terms of directing.

    I know Sho Kosugi from my '80s childhood days when director Sam Firstenberg was a profilic filmmaker of action movies with REVENGE OF THE NINJA and NINJA III: THE DOMINATION. It was a surprise to see him return after his long hiatus from movies and I hope that NINJA ASSASSIN will re-introduce him to the new generation of fans and they will go back and check out his classic ninja flicks.

    Well, I've said enough- in closing, despite the flaws and negative reviews from critics, NINJA ASSASSIN was a good movie from an entertaining standpoint and the film served its purpose; it was truly a masterpiece and I think the doors can possibly open for a sequel.

























  • ZenShiite
    With all the crap I've seen on this site assuming that Isaac Florentine's Ninja is the superior film to Ninja Assassin... I can confidently say, having watched both films today, that Ninja Assassin is the superior of the two. Yes, the martial arts aren't as showcased in NA as in Ninja... however, highly visible martial arts a good movie does not necessarily make. Not even a ninja movie. Ninja is your typical orphaned American becomes superior ninja master flick, and it's got all the hokiness of a Dudikoff flick. And I loved those movies. However, it's not nearly as adrenaline pumping as Ninja Assassin. Both have their fair share of CGI blood, but Florentine's Ninja is almost squeaky clean in comparison to NA. I enjoyed NA way more, and was far more awed by it. However, in both movies... the protagonists on the run from the evil ninja(s)/gangsters is tiresome. Particularly in Ninja, where the power of the ninja characters is simply non-existent. Even the female lead in that one, she seemingly can't fight her way out of a wet paper bag.
  • here we go again.
    lol, i love how people give their reviews and say this one is superior to that one!! seriously??! U expect a 5-6mill film to compete with or surpass a $40-50mill film, EVERYTHING will be be superior in the bigger budget one, stunts, effects, locations, sets, support, promotion, etc. BTW who said both needed powers? Anyway, just be happy we have some ninja action coming back..
  • GEE DUB
    THIS MOVIE ROCKED!!!!
  • noshadow284
    This movie was terrible. I'm honestly surprised its getting so much love on this site. The concerns over poorly edited and poorly shot action sequences previously expressed are more than valid. You can't see a thing during any of the fight sequences. For films like the Bourne Ultimatum, with substantial plot and decent acting, these short comings could be overlooked. However, in a film like Ninja Assassin, where the sole purpose of the film should be to showcase martial arts talent, this is simply to great an offense to be overlooked. Why can't hollywood learn from asian cinema and film fights so they can actually be seen and enjoyed?
  • DaRedLight
    From Twitch...Yahoo...and various othe sites, I have read the same complaints and questions. I will begin by writing...The movie Ninja Assassin was very entertaining. I have been interested in the genre for years! Understand these several points. Ninjas, though having historical tracking, were considered mystifying and mythical. Many practiced stealthy tactics of espionage, and assassinations. Many were Samurai who would carry out the orders of their Shogun. Their "attacks" were to be silent, swift...The shadows were their weapons. So when watching the movie, why wouldn't the scenes be fought in the dark. I think it is exaggerate to say the scenes were too dark. As compared...Batman's movies are always dark, especially "Batman Begins", no complaints there. Yes, Batman is a superhero movie, science fiction...Well Ninja Assassin is no documentary...lol! It too holds a fictional base. I believe the movie did well following the historical track of the Ninja in addition to the folklore/myths. The healing, though far - fetch, was considered to be an attribute, the superhuman speeds...maybe this was the best way for the director to give vision to how swift the Ninja was. No different from the Ninjas depicted in the movie "Elektra". I believe one should respect the performance of Rain, to have only trained for six months, and provide a more than adequate performance. Lastly; one goes to a Ninja movie to see Ninjas (which was satisfyingly provided). No one watched Terminator for Oscar award winning dialog. I also think there would be more complaints if there were an abundance of fights scenes with black garbed Ninjas fighting in a sun lit park...lol! To add to Mark's post about purchasing a ticket, Promoting this film can only help in increasing the quality level and availability in this market.
    I think we all could agree, we have seen enough of the "30 year old American male wiping out an entire Ninja Clan, trained from birth, only after a 2week Ninjutsu training with the old Clan's chef! lmao! Peace and blessings. - DaRedLight
  • It makes me happy to see this film getting accolades here - twitch hated the living CRAP out of this movie.
  • overall. the movie was great. felt a little short, maybe because of all the clips seen online prior to opening. i just hope they have a sequel and it deals a little more info regarding the other clans. only complain i would have to think of would be that there wasn't any real grappling in the movie in regards to Rain or any other character using those techniques. it would have been nice to see other 'ninjutsu' weaponry as well.
    i would give it a 4 out of 5 shuriken rating >_<
  • reefer
    Unfortunately, it felt like, despite all the fights, blood, guts, and mayhem thoughout, there was very little going on in Ninja Assassin. A little more charismatic lead actor may have helped. Rain comes off way dull, but his character may have been written that way. I know this is supposed to be comic book, over-the-top stuff, but, in other than a few scenes, the movie just takes itself too seriously.

    I love Mark's explanation or excuse for the dark fights and choppy editing. I totally buy it. Those of us who like our kung fu fighters squaring off like Jackie and Bennie in "Wheels on Meals" need to buy into the stealth nature of the ninja origin. McTeigue's film plays into the attacks from the shadows and the film is more original for it. I was kinda disappointed that Rain's opening skirmish in the laundromat wasn't a big time set piece. In the light of the laundromat, they could have gone with the full frame fight instead we see a flying sheet and lots of flailing arms. Then cut to bloody washing machine.

    While I am at it. The blood. There is lots of it. So much so that I had the compulsion once or twice to dodge in my seat as if I would eventually get some on me. People decapitated, malled, sliced, diced. Rain spends a lot of the final third of the film resembling the Jesus Christ from Mel Gibson's movie. My criticism of this would be the same I had for Tim Burton's "Sleepy Hollow". Once you see one head fly off someone's shoulders, the thrill is gone. The gory opening bloodbath pretty much set the tone and your expectations. So, without engaging characters, much of it just seemed repetitive.

    I'll end with the none too original revelation that Sho Kosugi is genuine ninja royalty. He is definitely a highlight here. So menacing. He saves the finale single-handedly and elevates my rating of the film to a 7 outa 10.
  • reefer
    maybe. It just seems like a missed opportunity to me. A cool location for some major fisticuffs. Against a female assassin. It would have come out of leftfield and set the film off to a rockin start.
  • I agree the laundromat scene seemed too short. I'm guessing it was meant as a teaser, to give us a suggestion of Raizo's abilities without revealing too much.
  • Rhythm-X
    Looking at the positive reactions to this I feel like I've stepped over to the Bizzaro Universe, where up is down, black is white, and NINJA ASSASSIN is competent martial arts filmmaking. I could have dealt with the full-on-retarded "story" in a film like this. It's really the terrible, terrible editing that destroys any enjoyability here. What a waste of potential this was.
  • sowutifmahsnsux
    just got back from seeing it with family. pretty much agree with Mark's review, and though the fights were a little dark and camera cut heavy, it could have been so much worse. it made it all the more refreshing when raizo fought the ninjas in the burning dojo, that was probably my favorite scene. the theatre was also packed and the audience applauded afterwords. hopefully mainstream moviegoers take a liking to this film and i would hope they make enough profit to consider investing in more films like this
  • I want to add that martial arts movie fans (who don't mind lots of gore) need to see this movie in the theater. It's all too rare to see an all-out martial arts movie like this in wide release. Also, I suspect the crazed action and dark lighting will probably not look as good on the small screen unless you have a decent-sized monitor. If for no other reason, buy a ticket to cast your vote in favor of seeing martial arts movies in theaters. It's a crime everything else without Jackie Chan or Jet Li in the lead role goes limited release or DTV.
  • Wurd, Preach, Preacha Man
  • Ab
    I posted in the forums too but it seems like I'm in the minority. I didn't like it all that much. Way to heavy on the CGI and dark, quick cutting closeups.
  • HeLL 2 the MuthaFawken YESH
  • Also, the first Resident Evil suxx baLLS, and yet even that series held Such Promise that it'd FinaLLY DeLiver'd in RE4, so yeas I'm hella excited by the cheesy Prospect for new, continued Entries the cheesier the better!! Can anyone say "Raizo versus Zombies"?
  • Tis not godsend or fur evreeone, but, if this was the kinda thing u've been dreaming of, u can't go wrong, one of the muthafawking guiltiest pleasures, not to mention, if this is what u've dream'd of, why not?
  • my take
    saw this film yesterday. and will see it again tomorrow. i waited for almost a year, searching every bit of info. i could about it's progression. inspite of the critques, which i paid no attention to, this film is everything the naysayers said it's not.
    ONE OF THE BEST ACTION FILMS of Martial Arts i have ever, and i mean ever seen. GO SEE IT FOR YOURSELF PEOPLE. don't let others make u miss out.
  • tikkiexx
    wow. im definately seeing this now. i know Mark had been skeptical of the movie for a while and if it got 4 stars from him its got to be good. good to hear that Rain did a good job in the film. well lets hope the movie is successfull which i think it will be after being bombarded with Ninja Assassin commercials for the last few weeks. then they can fix the flaws in the sequel or hopefully sequels. overall it sounds like the movie was a fun enjoyable experiance and thats all that really matters.
blog comments powered by Disqus