Wow.

What an absolutely fantastic film.

I can’t believe I almost cried at a martial arts movie.

Top five martial arts films ever.

These were all thoughts that ran through my head as the end credits rolled on MERANTAU, or MERANTAU WARRIOR as it’s being renamed in England.  It really was that good.  Why?  Let me count the ways.

Even though many will notice a distinct similarity with another recent action film which introduced a martial art largely ignored by action cinema, this film still remains its own distinct entity.  It feels only slightly unoriginal because of what Tony Jaa has done – the lead actor Iko Uwais even looks like him – but if you’re able to ignore trivial (and inevitable) similarities, MERANTAU WARRIOR will not disappoint.

The story concerns Yuda (Uwais) and his Merantau, a sort of rites-of-passage journey towards finding oneself that is a tradition in his community.  It involves him travelling to Jakarta and aiming to integrate into the society of the big city – in this case by teaching Silat.  Silat is an Indonesian martial art which hasn’t been substantially treated as a focus for a martial arts film before, but a few decades of neglect are certainly made up for in an hour and a half here.  It’s a powerful fighting style that consists of a multitude of punches, kicks, slaps, blocks, grappling, throws and any number of complex combos.  On screen it’s breath-taking, and although it’s clear that there’s a certain amount of artistic licence present in the fight sequences, it still remains an authentic and plausible fighting art that will delight in dropping jaws.

Each fight scene is better than the last and is also privy to the filmmakers cheeky method of allowing each bout to out-do its predessesor, a method akin to a horror film’s technique of only allowing a glimpse of a monster throughout the film before revealing its full fury at the conclusion.  What director Gareth Evans does here is to ensure that the first few fight scenes are only moderately exciting (even if they’re still better than the best scenes in many other films), before gradually building up the quality and complexity before finally unleashing what has to be one of the most pulse-pounding and relentless finales ever seen.

Once Uwais gets into his Silat groove, nothing can stop him.  He proves this through the unyielding barrage of fight scenes that comprise the huge climax.  This 20-odd minute adrenaline rush inexorably and ruthlessly kicks the viewer in the face with wave after unbelievable wave of persistently exhilarating and heady fight sequences.  Whereas most of the early fight scenes involve Uwais destroying armies of unskilled henchmen, towards the end he comes up against some bad guys with a little more martial prowess.  The first of which is a fantastic close quarters fight in an elevator which demonstrates the ferocity of a Silat vs. Silat punch-up, and the final stand-out pits Uwais against two western gangsters who also happen to be martial arts masters (even though Mads Koudal has no background in martial arts – certainly fooled me!).

Aside from the phenomenal fighting on display, every other ingredient in the ‘Good Film’ Pie is present.  The acting is acceptable from everyone, with some standing out a little more than others, and it’s worthy of note that the western actors used in MERANTAU WARRIOR are of a slightly higher quality than is usually found in eastern martial arts films (think back to the terrible acting displayed by westerners in some of Jet Li’s ‘90s output) even if Koudal’s accent does seem to have a life of its own.  This could possibly be down to the fact that Gareth Evans is Welsh and so will have brought a needed western influence into the casting process.

It’s also a well-rounded story that although similar to Jaa’s breakout hit, is allowed to go in a slightly different direction which results in it being a far more nuanced, relatable and most importantly, emotional film than ONG BAK.  It’s a cliché to say that a film makes you care for the characters, but in this case it really does.  Uwais is not a complete one-note killing machine and displays a subtle emotion regardless of his limited lines and chance to develop within the story, and it’s this evocation of pathos that makes him a perfect central pin for around which to hang the film.  This moving performance resulted in, as I mentioned at the beginning, me stifling back the tears, and that’s an unusual occurance when watching a martial arts film (apart from BEST OF THE BEST, which had me bawling like a baby, but still).

Overall, MERANTAU WARRIOR was truthfully one of the best martial arts films I’ve seen and is such a must-see that it’s almost frustrating.  It has everything that’s needed for a great action film; relatable and engaging characters, heart-warming sentiment, an engrossing central concept and fight scenes so good you’ll want to watch them on repeat for at least a week.  It’s not quite a five star film, mainly due to the odd bit of dodgy acting and its similarities to other recent movies, but it’s so close that it doesn’t really matter.  All that’s left to give is the following piece of advice:

SEE THIS FILM.

MERANTAU WARRIOR will be released on Region 2 DVD on 26th April by E1 Entertainment

REVIEW: Merantau Warrior (2009), 8.9 out of 10 based on 44 ratings

by

Related Topics:
 •   •   • 
  • xstukeyx

    Okay, I see this film is at that action fest you wrote about, does that mean it'll get a US release soon? I downloaded a version awhile ago but it had no subtitles. would love to see this film..

  • poulos25

    Is it the 100 minute version. I read that the film is 130 minutes long and they cut nearly 30 minutes.

  • GazzO

    This version was 106 minutes long but the Region 2 DVD which comes out on the 26th April has deleted scenes so I guess these are the ones cut from the longer version, but I'm not sure.

  • http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=152159&id=632433813 Hassei dan shirei

    Mads have basic martial art actually :) but perhaps not really expert like Laurent Buson or Iko uwais :

    Mads Koudal has done a bit wing tsun, karate and boxing.

    Nice review :)

  • http://www.wirthconsulting.org Kraak Mo

    Wow, I've never read such a strong endorsement from Master Pollard. You can be sure that I'm going to see this film!

  • GazzO

    Kraak Mo, Mark didn't actually write this review, it was me!

  • http://www.wirthconsulting.org Kraak Mo

    You are an excellent pupil Brother Gazz! Nice work! I am sorry that I didn't pay attention to your byline. Fogive me, I promise to be more attentive in the future.

  • Goldie_Hawn_Golden_Shower

    it kicked a ton of ass.. Everyone involved including the extras did a fantastic job, looking forward to see their next project…

  • njwarrior

    Okay based on this review, I had to watch this movie asap so I downloaded it. I have to admit that I REALLY enjoyed the movie. Yes the actor reminded me a lot of Tony Jaa but I really want to see more movies with Iko. His fighting style is sick. The only thing that upset me was the ending and it was kind of predictable. Why aren't these movies released in USA theaters? Movies like these along with IP Man need more exposure. The average martial arts fan is missing out on these great movies!

  • bob

    I think the action is so immature but its just one of those ' I've got nothing to lose, I'm going all out unleashing my rage and defeat final boss movies.

    Junkie violence at its extreme, of course weeks, possibly months spent to choreograph. Awful film to be honest. Storyline predictable, and outfit of main character is stereotyped.

  • tobey

    I'm Indonesian and I'm proud of this. This movie also feature Indonesian legendary actress Christine Hakim as Uwais' mother. There're couple of plot hole, but overall it's a satisfying action piece. Word on the street is: Uwais and Evans are wrapping another actioner called ” Berandal”. Cross your fingers it will be as good or even better than “Merantau Warrior”

  • Adhipar

    I watched the full version in the movie and then I also has a chance to see the shorter one. The full one is a bit slow in pace but contain a fight scene which I think should be included in the 106 mins version.

    The small guy (forgot his name) who fight Iko in the elevator actually has a fight scene with a big guy and win. So you can imagine what the audience feel when this guy – who actually know Iko, has all the skill and finally have to fight our hero in that elevator.

    I wish Gareth cut more of those mother and son dialogues at the beginning of the movie and add this fight scene.

  • stfu faggots

    stfu indonesian weaklings….you really think that shit's gonna fly in a real fight? FFS even his standing stance has no root

  • Carpe

    It's a movie, not real fight. Stop being stupid, watch a movie knowing it's a movie if you want real life/fight check for real war videos.

  • darrinkemp

    I almost never do this but,your racial bullshit anoyes me.So what can you do?Whats your style and how many real fights have you been in that you can tell other people what will and wont work in a fight?Its a movie.

  • Goldie_Hawn_Golden_Shower

    @stfu faggots…. Dude what is with you??? Get the hell out of here u don't belong here go back to the basement and lubricant.. Don't you need to inseminate your goat??

  • albertv

    okay, let's keep it all clean. I personally have not seen the movie yet, but will be checking it out this week, but have heard a lot of good rave, including here…great review Gazz.

  • Adhipar

    FYI, Iko is a Champion of Indonesia's Pencak Silat Tournament 2005, so he know his stuff well. Whether a movie, a TV show or a tournament, they have 'game rules' which makes them interesting to watch. A real fight with no rules? Just bring out some dynamites, guns/weapons, fire, etc which will end the fight in second, your standing stance with heavy root won't give you any advantage.

  • stfu faggots

    Hush, I'm not done with your arse yet. Will get back to my goat in a while

  • stfu faggots

    Champion of some tournament. Wow, colour me impressed. I'll tell you my style when we meet in a back alley.

  • cris

    What is ur style? doggy style? bend over style? sorry not interested

  • stfu faggots

    Hi cris,
    Yes, you guessed right. Please bend over now. Time to be my bitch. You might consider using some punctuation and letter capitalization as well.

    All trolling aside: You guys fail miserably. A bunch of martial arts flick nerds getting all buttsore over some random troll. Too much of pent up aggression I say.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=515928872 Stephen Ma

    Saw the movie yesterday…and sadly I have to disagree and say this movie is mediocre at best. The story was well told, had substance, and was touching at moments…which says a lot about a martial arts film. Contrary to films like Onk Bak series, Raging Phoenix, and other movies where the movie is essentially an 1.5 hour highlight reel, this movie had heart. But unfortunately, it fails in the martial arts department.

    While I really appreciate the style of Indonesian martial arts (somewhat similar to a toned down version of capoeira in its movements), I can't really see Silat as effective if faced with other, more established styles. There's no real “stance”, which could be a good thing in a real fight, but it looks unrefined, hesitant and indecisive. I couldn't tell if Iko Uwais was nervous or was it part of his fighting style. The fighting, while plentiful, was not fulfilling. Almost bland. There were never once where I got the “kick” I expected from any fight scene. I never felt the emotional (yea, give it to him!!!) punch being delivered. Each fight scene seems like it “wanted” to cross the threshold to entertaining, but stayed in mediocre mode instead.

    Again, I say that I respect the Silat style, and maybe it is effective in its own right, but I can say that it doesn't make for entertaining fighting scenes. And I can't in good conscience blindly praise something just because it hasn't been done before in martial arts film. Too bad too, I was really expecting something great.

    Rating: 2.5/4 Stars

  • Adhipar

    Yes, you have good point on the entertaining fighting scenes. Trained in Pencak Silat for years myself, I do know that Pencak Silat, at least the style I learned – there are lots of style from different region of Indonesia – is not 'pretty' cause it designed to beat your opponent effectively (fast but with so little effort/power as you can), targeting on human weakest points even create that weakness first.

    Sort of aikido but aiming to hurt the opponent badly even deadly. For instance, there's no high kick or turning kick, because in a close fight, it will open your defense widely. We're not also punch/kick as hard as we can since it will cost our balance. So, I could say it's somewhat 'ugly'. You're also right about no real stance which show the opponent : hey, I am about to punch/kick you.

    Therefore, in tournament, tv shows, demonstration etc, they are restrained themselves and only perform the 'art' stuff, some pretty but useless move. Also in this movie.

    Since I'm aware of this, I can enjoy the film. Just like I enjoy Jacky Chan's “Shinjuku Incident”. Not like any other Chan's movie, the fight is so (like you said) bland. But that's actually close to what a real fight is.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=515928872 Stephen Ma

    Very informative…I'm personally not too familiar with Silat, so it's nice to have somebody who practices to comment. Yea absolutely, real fighting is not showy, and probably includes many more grapples and rolling around (MMA). I hope they make a few more films like this so I can familiarize myself with Silat more.

  • Adhipar

    Gareth and Iko are making another movie called “Berandal”. This title can have several meanings and no words about the story yet but I hope it's about “wiseman” or “street fighter”. Just wait and see :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/loctaip Loc Pham

    When any “poseurs” or Critics Learn to STFU, and Make your “own” Movie, then we wiLL: appreciate thy “OpinionS” untiL THEN: STFU, neh?

  • Rhythm-X

    I wonder, if you were to buy a brand new car that turned out to be a complete, failure-prone hunk of shit that tended to shed parts when it hit potholes, how you'd feel about having it towed back to the dealer only to be told “What the hell are you complaining about, let's see you make a better car!” Would you say, “You're absolutely right – a thousand apologies, I was completely out of line, and I'll be going now.” – somehow I don't see it happening. I haven't even seen the film, but this line of reasoning is as weak as it is common.

  • Egeaux

    This has to be the best introduction film since Ong-Bak. I could not believe how good this film was. I first heard about Silat in Mortal Kombat:Deception, but Baraka isn't exactly a good representation.This guy should make more movies that show off the brutality of Silat-Harimau because he can be the next big star.

  • http://www.nike-airjordan-retro.com nike air jordan

    This has to be the best introduction film since Ong-Bak. I could not
    believe how good this film was. I first heard about Silat in Mortal
    Kombat:Deception, but Baraka isn't exactly a good representation.This
    guy should make more movies that show off the brutality of Silat-Harimau
    because he can be the next big star.

  • http://www.nike-airjordan-retro.com nike air jordan

    This has to be the best introduction film since Ong-Bak. I could not
    believe how good this film was. I first heard about Silat in Mortal
    Kombat:Deception, but Baraka isn't exactly a good representation.This
    guy should make more movies that show off the brutality of Silat-Harimau
    because he can be the next big star.